GameStop - Wall Street vs the internet
How Reddit Took On the Hedge Funds Over GameStop
At the start of January 2021, GameStop was a struggling mall retailer with a share price of about $17. By the end of the month, its stock had touched $483, Robinhood had shut its doors to new buyers, and a Congressional hearing was being scheduled to ask how a video game chain had shaken Wall Street.
The story began with a bet that looked like a sure thing. By the start of 2021, short sellers had borrowed and sold so many GameStop shares that the total exceeded the public float. Estimates ranged from about 114% to over 140%, meaning more shares had been sold short than existed for trading. Hedge funds were betting the stock would keep falling, and one of the biggest was Melvin Capital, which had a $12.5 billion portfolio and had shorted GameStop heavily.
What is short selling?
Short selling is betting that a stock’s price will fall. You borrow shares, sell them, then buy them back later, hopefully at a lower price, and return them.
You profit from the drop. But if the price rises instead, your losses can keep growing with no limit.
Here’s a quick example with 10 shares:
Win: You borrow 10 shares and sell them at €100 each, getting €1,000.
The price drops to €60, so you buy them back for $600 and return them. Profit: €1,000 − €600 = You make €400.
Loss: Same start, but the price rises to €150. You must buy back for €1,500 and return them. Loss: €1,000 − €1,500 = you lose $500.
When the Market Started to Crack
Melvin Capital took the worst of it. The fund lost 53% in January, and in late January, Citadel and Point72 injected a combined $2.75 billion to keep it afloat: $2 billion from Citadel and $750 million from Point72. Melvin closed its doors in May 2022. Across the market, short sellers were estimated to have lost about $6 billion by January 26 alone.
Then the plumbing started to crack. On January 28, Robinhood stopped customers from opening new positions in GameStop, AMC and a handful of other volatile stocks, though they could still sell. Other brokers followed. Robinhood said the restrictions were forced by the clearing system, which had raised collateral requirements. The Depository Trust & Clearing Corporation’s total industry collateral demands climbed from $26 billion to $33.5 billion. Critics saw the move as protecting hedge funds at the expense of retail traders, and the backlash was swift.
When Wall Street Went to Washington
The story had a major political chapter too. On February 18, 2021, the House Financial Services Committee, chaired by Maxine Waters, held a hearing titled “Game Stopped? Who Wins and Loses When Short Sellers, Social Media, and Retail Investors Collide.” Witnesses included Robinhood CEO Vlad Tenev, Citadel’s Ken Griffin, Reddit CEO Steve Huffman, Melvin’s Gabe Plotkin, and Keith Gill. Griffin denied that Citadel had pressured Robinhood. Gill told lawmakers he was “not an institutional investor, nor am I a hedge fund.”
Behind the drama was a quieter figure: Ryan Cohen. He had revealed a 9% stake in GameStop in August 2020, and he joined the board on January 11, 2021. Within months he was chairman, pushing the company toward e-commerce.
The short squeeze was one of the most dramatic episodes of modern markets. It exposed how thinly traded stocks can be turned into weapons, and it raised questions about who really gets protected when markets seize up.